An American Crime (2007) featured a cast of 28 tracked actors. Of these, 20 (95%) are still alive today and 1 have passed away. The oldest surviving cast member is Michael O'Keefe, age 71. This film starred Elliot Page and Catherine Keener.
95% still with us· verified cast71% of full cast · incl. 7 unverified
Survivorship
Cast Reunion Index: 95% still living
Avg. Age at Death: 83 yrs
Deaths by Year
2008
Cast28 members
| Person | Character | Status | DOB | Age | DOD | Age in 2007 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 Elliot Page Sylvia Likens | Sylvia Likens | Living | 21/02/1987 | 39 | — | 20 |
 Catherine Keener Gertrude Baniszewski | Gertrude Baniszewski | Living | 26/03/1959 | 67 | — | 48 |
 Hayley McFarland Jennifer Faye 'Jennie' Likens | Jennifer Faye 'Jennie' Likens | Living | 29/03/1991 | 35 | — | 16 |
 Nick Searcy Lester Likens | Lester Likens | Living | 07/03/1959 | 67 | — | 48 |
 Romy Rosemont Betty Likens | Betty Likens | Living | 28/10/1964 | 61 | — | 43 |
 Ari Graynor Paula Baniszewski | Paula Baniszewski | Living | 27/04/1983 | 43 | — | 24 |
 Scout Taylor-Compton Stephanie Baniszewski | Stephanie Baniszewski | Living | 21/02/1989 | 37 | — | 18 |
 Tristan Jarred Johnny Baniszewski | Johnny Baniszewski | Living | 03/06/1994 | 32 | — | 13 |
 Hannah Leigh Shirley Baniszewski | Shirley Baniszewski | Living | 15/11/1996 | 29 | — | 11 |
 Bradley Whitford Prosecutor | Prosecutor | Living | 10/10/1959 | 66 | — | 48 |
 James Franco Andy | Andy | Living | 19/04/1978 | 48 | — | 29 |
 Scott Eastwood Eric | Eric | Living | 21/03/1986 | 40 | — | 21 |
 Michael O'Keefe Reverend Bill Collier | Reverend Bill Collier | Living | 24/04/1955 | 71 | — | 52 |
 Carlie Westerman Marie Baniszewski | Marie Baniszewski | Unverified | — | — | — | — |
 Michelle Benes Hope Orbach | Hope Orbach | Unverified | — | — | — | — |
 Jeremy Sumpter Coy Hubbard | Coy Hubbard | Living | 05/02/1989 | 37 | — | 18 |
 Brian Geraghty Bradley | Bradley | Living | 13/05/1974 | 52 | — | 33 |
 Channing Nichols Patty | Patty | Living | 23/11/1993 | 32 | — | 14 |
 Michael Welch Teddy | Teddy | Living | 25/07/1987 | 39 | — | 20 |
 Evan Peters Ricky Hobbs | Ricky Hobbs | Living | 20/01/1987 | 39 | — | 20 |
 Amy Ferguson Sally | Sally | Unverified | — | — | — | — |
 Will Carter Officer Waters | Officer Waters | Living | 19/04/1968 | 58 | — | 39 |
 Edward James Gage Bailiff | Bailiff | Living | 24/04/1960 | 66 | — | 47 |
 Patricia Place Mrs. Doyle | Mrs. Doyle | Deceased | 07/12/1924 | 83 | 20/09/2008 | 83 |
 Paul Grace Cottin Candy Vendor (uncredited) | Cottin Candy Vendor (uncredited) | Unverified | — | — | — | — |
James Meehan Defense Attorney (uncredited) | Defense Attorney (uncredited) | Unverified | — | — | — | — |
Paul Palo Newspaper Reporter (uncredited) | Newspaper Reporter (uncredited) | Unverified | — | — | — | — |
 Gary Sievers Carnie (uncredited) | Carnie (uncredited) | Unverified | — | — | — | — |