The Amityville Horror (2005) featured a cast of 22 tracked actors. Of these, 10 (83%) are still alive today and 2 have passed away. The oldest surviving cast member is Danny McCarthy, age 57. This film starred Ryan Reynolds and Melissa George.
83% still with us· verified cast45% of full cast · incl. 10 unverified
Survivorship
Cast Reunion Index: 83% still living
Avg. Age at Death: 91 yrs
Deaths by Year
2020
2022
Cast22 members
| Person | Character | Status | DOB | Age | DOD | Age in 2005 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 Ryan Reynolds George Lutz | George Lutz | Living | 23/10/1976 | 49 | — | 29 |
 Melissa George Kathy Lutz | Kathy Lutz | Living | 06/08/1976 | 50 | — | 29 |
 Jesse James Billy Lutz | Billy Lutz | Living | 14/09/1989 | 37 | — | 16 |
 Jimmy Bennett Michael Lutz | Michael Lutz | Living | 09/02/1996 | 30 | — | 9 |
 Chloë Grace Moretz Chelsea Lutz | Chelsea Lutz | Living | 10/02/1997 | 29 | — | 8 |
 Rachel Nichols Lisa | Lisa | Living | 08/01/1980 | 46 | — | 25 |
 Philip Baker Hall Father Callaway | Father Callaway | Deceased | 10/09/1931 | 90 | 12/06/2022 | 74 |
 Isabel Conner Jodie Defeo | Jodie Defeo | Living | 15/04/1997 | 29 | — | 8 |
Brendan Donaldson Ronald Defeo | Ronald Defeo | Unverified | — | — | — | — |
 Annabel Armour Realtor | Realtor | Unverified | — | — | — | — |
 Rich Komenich Chief of Police | Chief of Police | Unverified | — | — | — | — |
 David Gee ER Doctor | ER Doctor | Unverified | — | — | — | — |
 Danny McCarthy Officer Greguski | Officer Greguski | Living | 09/02/1969 | 57 | — | 36 |
Nancy Lollar Librarian | Librarian | Deceased | 30/07/1928 | 92 | 07/10/2020 | 77 |
José Taitano Stitch | Stitch | Unverified | — | — | — | — |
 Lenore Thomas Nurse Fuller | Nurse Fuller | Living | 13/04/1970 | 56 | — | 35 |
Marie Joelyn Store Patron | Store Patron | Unverified | — | — | — | — |
 Dorian Kingi Scary Leashed Indian | Scary Leashed Indian | Living | 25/09/1982 | 43 | — | 23 |
Alan Koeppen Paramedic | Paramedic | Unverified | — | — | — | — |
Ryan Kross Restaurant patron | Restaurant patron | Unverified | — | — | — | — |
Sam Raysby New York State Trooper | New York State Trooper | Unverified | — | — | — | — |
 Jenny Strubin Grocery Cashier | Grocery Cashier | Unverified | — | — | — | — |